Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Can you put vacuum in a bottle in any more real sense than you can put darkness in a bottle, or cold, or dry?


Phrases found from a Google search for "put vacuum in"

"hand vacuum pump (the one that you can use to bleed brakes with) and hook up the line directly to the actuator and put vacuum in it"

"I was wondering if anyone has experimented with a vacuum pump or any other way to put vacuum in the crankcase."

"I believe VW uses an air pump to test the evap system instead of relying on engine vacuum to put vacuum in the evap system"

"I want to be able to put vacuum in and leave it but not sure why no suction?"

It seems that many people regard it as having a concrete meaning. (I saw little hit of a non-concrete meaning. The other cases I saw were things like "put vacuum in pool", in reference to a vacuum cleaner.)

There were 138 non-duplicate matches for "put darkness in". All were metaphorical, and most were due to a Biblical verse.

While there are some references to "put cold in", as in:

"If you put cold in the thermostat doesn't kick on until much later causing the water to freeze at a later time."

"it's identical to a regular hotwater tank so you have to put cold in to the drain and loop it back"

they are short-hand for "cold water". Otherwise the terms are either metaphorical, like "put cold in its place with this warm parka", or a reminder that chilling devices don't put cold in but rather take heat out.

The phrase "put dry in" only appears in context like "Get 2 [dog] bowls and put dry in 1", or "I didn't have fresh basil so I put dry in the mayo", where the "dry" refers to a preceding noun. (The one exception was the question "why would they want to put dry in their beer?".)

Thus, a haphazard search of the Google corpus reinforces my assertion that putting vacuum in (something) has a more real, concrete sense than putting darkness, cold, or dry in (something).


Yes. Obviously, you just remove the air in the bottle and then there is a vacuum (or as good of an approximation of it as you can obtain using your techniques) inside the bottle.


Personally I would call that 'creating vacuum in a bottle' rather than 'putting vacuum in a bottle.' Putting it into a bottle implies that it was something that existed outside of the bottle and it then transferred into the bottle.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: