Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I've really heard is "lobbying is free speech, corporations need free speech".

Is it bad if I write a letter or talk with my congress critter? How about if I put up a sign?

How about if you and I get together to do so?

Corporations are voluntary aggregations of people.



Actually, a corporation is an entity empowered by law to do certain things (e.g., shield its owners from personal liability) that a mere aggregation of people cannot do. The Supreme Court majority in the Citizens United case missed this important distinction.

I think it’s possible to draw logical and constitutional lines between

¶ 100 people writing letters to their Congresscritters advocating for the same policy

¶ a manager of a corporation (with 100 shareholders) writing Congresscritters to advocate for some policy (that not all 100 shareholders think is a good idea)

¶ a corporation hiring a lobbyist to be its permanent advocate in Washington


> a manager of a corporation (with 100 shareholders) writing Congresscritters to advocate for some policy (that not all 100 shareholders think is a good idea)

Actually, those shareholders do think that it's a good idea because they've continued to be shareholders.

> corporation hiring a lobbyist to be its permanent advocate in Washington

That's just like me than me writing a letter every day.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: